0.1: Description of Cicero created by Klaas Dellschaft 0.2: Adapted by Aldo Gangemi for linking to codolight 0.3: Revised a redundant axiom for CiceroWikiWorkflow 0.4: Made broad refactoring after more careful analysis. Refactored UserType subclasses as individuals; also refactored the anonymous typing dependent on those classes as simple object values; added import of specialization.owl pattern; refactored rdf:type axioms to DesignOperation as inputType axioms to DesignFunctionality; also refactored the executesTask axioms dependent on those individuals as isPartOf axioms. 0.5: added labels and knowledge types 0.6: corrected bug in type of CiceroWikiWorkfow
Cicero solution proposal
Cicero solution proposal KType
Cast vote
Cicero argument KType
Casting a single vote for one of the proposed solutions.
The preferential voting is an optional phase in the workflow of the Cicero Wiki.
Preferential voting
Decide on solution
An Issue Moderator decides, which solution should be implemented in the ontology project. The decision is based on the previous discussion and may be based on a previously held preferential voting.
Take decision
Create annotation
Cicero issue KType
Create issue
Creating a new issue that should be discussed in the following.
Annotating ontology elements with a discussion in the Cicero Wiki.
Cicero toolkit plugin
The Cicero Plugin for the NeOn Toolkit can be used for annotating ontology elements with related discussions in a Cicero Argumentation Wiki.
Project member
Cicero wiki
The Cicero Argumentation Wiki can be used for discussing issues that are raised during an OntologyProject with regard to the development of the ontology.
Discuss design rationale
During the discussion of an issue, the members of a project exchange solution proposals and arguments.
Issue moderator
Cicero administrator
Create project
Creating a new discussion project that groups all discussions related to a specific ontology project.
Cicero wiki workflow
A single solution is proposed how to solve the previously raised issue.
Propose solution
Cicero toolkit plugin workflow
An Issue Moderator explicitly starts a preferential voting. This phase is optional, i.e. either an Issue Moderator can directly take a decision or an automatic transistion into the PreferentialVoting phase is triggered after a certain time.
Start preferential voting
Project moderator
A supporting or objecting argument with regard to a specific solution proposal is given.
Provide argument
Cicero issue
Cicero argument